Suspect thaler witcher 2 However, it is only after the attack in the hospital did the criminal boss become a suspect. Phases [] The Permit [] The gravedigger says the cemetery should be full of clues. Phase 2. This page is a quick reference to all Secondary quests in The Witcher. After the attack on the Detective by Salamandra, Geralt learnt that Leuvaarden is another suspect in Raymond's book, which makes a lot of sense: Running an organization as Pretty simple question really. The problem is, though, that I can't seem to prove Thaler innocent. Suspect: Leuvaarden is a sub-quest of Vizima Confidential in Chapter II. Although this ring can not be bought initially, once acquired, it can be sold and then repurchased The cemetery crypt is located inside Vizima's cemetery, in the north section. She participated in the Battle of Brenna as part of the staff Vizima Confidential is basically the framing quest for Chapter II of The Witcher. It seems very strange that the Salamandra thugs knew exactly where to find the witcher at that Suspect: Kalkstein is a sub-quest of Vizima Confidential in Chapter II. When Geralt follows a trail of lost THE WITCHER THE WITCHER 2 (PC) THE WITCHER 2 (XBOX) THE WITCHER 3 (PC) THE WITCHER 3 (PLAYSTATION) THE WITCHER 3 (XBOX) THE WITCHER Thaler, (5) Vincent and (6) Vivaldi. There is no visible signature on the letter. Him hires Berengar (info from Thaler) 3. In this quest, with the help of the local private Hello viewers welcome to part 21 of the Witcher Enhanced Edition Director's cut. patreon. Possible spoilers ahead! In chapter 2, Thaler told me that he was tired of the investigation and that I needed to prove him innocent before I could deal with the gravedigger's debts. Check out the Witcher Wiki's pages on Suspect: Thaler and Suspect: Vincent Meiss for walkthroughs. I'll let you know if I end up doing that, though it'll probably be a few months at minimum if I do. After some time A Gravedigger's Gratitude is an entirely optional sub-quest of Vizima Confidential. About Press Copyright Contact us Creators Advertise Developers Terms Privacy Policy & Safety How YouTube works Test new features NFL Sunday Ticket Press Copyright The cemetery option came up for Thaler but he won't help me unless I can prove his innocence. It allows entry into one of two semi-restricted areas within the Temple Quarter: the dike and St. It is not strictly necessary to the completion of the investigation as a whole, despite being one of the most influential. but now i want to found some evidence for complete the suspect quest. The Mysterious Owner. I do not have the quest "Suspect: Thaler" anymore I do not have the quest "Suspect: Vincent" anymore I have gotten to the questline for Shani's Party, I have completed Thaler will not help Geralt get into the cemetery until he is proven innocent in the Suspect: Thaler quest. Depending on the Suspect: Thorak is a secondary quest in Chapter 2 of The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings. How do I prove Thaler innocent so that I can get the graveyard/cemetary key ~ go find that special corpse I need to find to put an end to this silly chapter. What do I have to do to spot him? He never appears at night and resting in Thaler's house until midnight won't help. 38 Suspect: Thaler. Phase 12. something about an autopsy that i don't know how to start. After the Nilfgaardian invasion of Temeria, Thaler has found himself north of Velen, in Novigrad. Thaler. Phase 13. To enter the cemitery you have to prove Thaler or Vincent innocent, I proved Thaler first. I tend to know what I'm doing when I prescribe something. This quest is initiated near the end of The Beast of the Sewers when Geralt realizes that Vincent was one of the few people who knew he was in the sewers. 0 - Prison Break 11. Let me explain what quests I have and what I have acomplished. He poses as a cobbler called Clogs while collaborating with multiple parties in the scheme to restore the former realm to its previous glory. Walkthrough []. With almost every clue about the alchemist obscured by currently unreachable ends, like the mysterious witcher Suspect: Thaler is a sub-quest of Vizima Confidential in Chapter II. My journal has already updated and I've proven everyone innocent at this point except Kalkstein. com/GamesWalkthroughGamesStreamLabs: https://bit. The witcher has been following the trails of Salamandra and in this quest, he finally gained a step ahead of Azar Javed. After listening I am playing The Witcher trilogy in preparation for the upcoming update to The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. Can't get into cemetary (even after finishing suspect: thaler/vincent quests) So, I'm in Act II and can't get into the Vizima Cemetary. Suspect: Thaler The Mysterious man retires to what seems to be his home around midnight, a house which is to the right of the hospital. Γκέραλτ must get the body of the crown witness out of the cemetery and to Νοσοκομείο της Αγ. but i don't know how to If you give him the book you won from Thaler in the drinking contest “Shadow People, This updates the quest “Vizima Confidential” and starts the quest “Suspect: Notes on how your choices in The Witcher will carry over to The Witcher 2. There are a couple of ways List of suspects is a quest item in The Witcher which is obtained by talking to Raymond Maarloeve during the investigation of Salamandra in Chapter II. i read guides that lead to either going to the cemetary (which i cant get into Vincent wont talk to me and i don't know how to let thaler get me in. Actually, The Witcher; The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings; The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. A number of things impact this little side quest. I've already cleared Ramsmeat of wrongdoing and I don't have any more active tasks on the suspect: Kalkstein quest. It can either be completed by proving all the suspects innocent at once, or by proving only Thaler's innocence. YES! Got full game today. this means you did autospy wrong. ). Recent Posts. . jolietjake Senior user #5 Aug 21, 2009. Lebioda's Hospital garden and just around the corner from the City Dungeon. Reading it is the only way to spawn the sub-quest below involving Leuvaarden. 1 suspect in the investigation, Kalkstein is the most diffcult suspect to clear of suspicion of collaborating with Salamandra. This quest is initiated near the end of The Beast of the Sewers when Γκέραλτ realizes that Vincent was one of the few people who knew he was in the sewers. During this procedure, Geralt Suspect: Vincent Meis is a sub-quest of Vizima Confidential in Chapter II. (which invariably makes Suspect Suspect: Vivaldi is a sub-quest of Vizima Confidential in Chapter II. Back: The Witcher Chapter 2 . As the famous, or should we say infamous "King of the underworld", Ramsmeat is sure to catch our hero's attention. 0 - An Old Friend of Mine 15. Vincent is still listed as a potential suspect (seems like I need to exonerate him somehow also). A Gravedigger's Gratitude Dice Poker: The Professional Suspect: Thaler Geralt can sleep here for free in Chapter II. The series follows Geralt of Rivia, a monster hunter in a universe where people often prove more wicked than beasts. During the autopsy Geralt and Shani concluded that Kalkstein was guilty, but I don't believe that (it could've been anyone with access to alchemist poison). Thaler's place is on Heroes on the Guard Street, facing the back entrance to St. This is my 5th or 6th playthrough of this game, but it h All things related to The Witcher - books, games, TV You name it. you cant open cemetry in chapter 2 now. A number of You can clear Thaler by either discovering the real culprit during the autopsy, or finding out three clues (one by talking to Thaler himself, another by talking to Jethro, and one more by finding Once you have some Fisstech, give it to Jethro and ask him about the Silver Sword to start the quest “Suspect: Thaler”. To do it, the easiest way for me was to go to Shani's party, after the authopsy, and after the party giving her Red Roses, this will maker her give you evidences of Thaler is innocent, than go to him and get the "pass The Witcher; Suspect Thaler/Mysterious Man; Topic Archived; More Topics from this Board. Lebioda's Hospital so that he and Shani can perform an autopsy to try to determine how he was killed and by whom. w2strings files (or at least the ones for This is a quest item. As the No. Demo Witcher. 0 - Wanted 12. Following Raymond's advice about The Witcher; The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings; The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. Depending on the order you do Suspect: Kalkstein Clues OK , I wanted to try to clear him up using clues before finding find Raymond's body, or autopsy. You can clear Thaler by either discovering the real culprit during The mysterious man is someone who can be found lurking outside Thaler's place in the Temple Quarter at night. 0 - What Lies thaler is not guilty. 893 446 337MB Read more. I've also talked to Thaler and Leuwaarden to the point that they don't have any more dialogue options For The Witcher on the PC, a GameFAQs message board topic titled "Chapter 2 - Getting into the cemetary *spoilers*". 1340) was a medic, having studied at Oxenfurt Academy. This phase begins after you It is Vizma Condidential. This part we take out a couple of dogs to finish gathering for the Dogcatche This mean completing the Suspect: Vincent Meis for Vincent or the Suspect: Thaler quest for Thaler. This initiates the quest as Geralt is suspicious of the dwarf given that the money which The Alghoul Contract is a contract quest in The Witcher. Even if it is not necessary to successfully complete it, or leave it uncompleted (the quest will automatically fail at the end of the Chapter), it is connected with a primary quest, Royal Blood. I've exonerated Thaler, Vivaldi, and Ramsmeat as a result, and gotten some info from them. just head ch3 and cemetery will be open I never said Thaler was guily, he was proven innocent in my game. If this quest is solved before the autopsy, it makes the Anatomy of a Crime quest that much easier by eliminating Ramsmeat as a suspect and thus steering Geralt toward either Kalkstein or Azar Javed as the culprit. Outside the cemetery's main gates in the Temple Quarter, Geralt encountered the lone Gravedigger hammering nails into freshly built coffins. 0 - Memory of a Blade 14. 1 post, 1/11/2023. All the side quests in the game, including free-form quests, notice board quests, trophy hunts Suspect: Ramsmeat is a sub-quest of Vizima Confidential in Chapter II. Whether or not Coleman gets killed certainly has a major impact. The Witcher is a critically acclaimed fantasy book series created by Andrzej Sapkowski. If you did save him, additionally in The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings you'll get a package and a message from Thaler when you are in Flotsam. This side quest only The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings. From wiki it says there are 3 clues: 1. He had a strong addiction to fisstech which Anatomy of a Crime is a quest which Γκέραλτ receives from Raymond Maarloeve in Chapter II as part of his investigation into the Salamandra organization in Vizima and his quest to find and neutralize its leader, Azar Javed. Prison Break. This phase begins together with phase 2 of Q2. i even THE WITCHER THE WITCHER 2 (PC) THE WITCHER 2 (XBOX) THE WITCHER 3 (PC) THE WITCHER 3 (PLAYSTATION) THE WITCHER 3 (XBOX) THE WITCHER 3 (SWITCH) COMMUNITY. . Further interrogations. My suspoct quests are as follows right THE WITCHER THE WITCHER 2 (PC) THE WITCHER 2 (XBOX) THE WITCHER 3 (PC) THE WITCHER 3 (PLAYSTATION) THE WITCHER 3 (XBOX) THE WITCHER 3 (SWITCH) COMMUNITY. This quest is given to the witcher by detective Raymond Maarloeve when the two first meet. Sword of Destiny I clicked the man, got 100 xp as he said something about not saying I'd seen him there, and my Suspect: Thaler quest updated from the second step, lack of evidence, to a third step, Guilty the suspect i still have to solve are: -Ramsmeat -Thaler -Kalkstein the bandits have already attacked the hospital and they also attacked raymond in his house, and now is gone. He then tells him that Berengar left a Suspect: Ramsmeat is a sub-quest of Vizima Confidential in Chapter II. Suspect: Vincent Meis is a sub-quest of Vizima Confidential in Chapter II. I have a psychological need to do all dialogues,so I pressed charges to absolutely every suspect. When Geralt meets Yaevinn for the first time in the Druids' grove, if the witcher accepts to deliver a letter to Vizima for the elf, he learns of Golan Vivaldi, a dwarven banker. He will give you the Cemetery Key along with the formula for Petri’s Philter . He worked for Vincent Meis officially, but seemed to have quite the little enterprise on the side as well. References: All the King's Men, A Posh Reception, Dragon's Dream (bomb), Blue Eyes [] Find you Witcher 2 installation directory. In His Thaler accuses royal edicts presented by de Wett as being a forgery. That's the only way out the game gives you if you mess up the whole thing as I Spoiler Note in later games: Even if Thaler dies, he'll re-appear in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt, regardless of your choice. Following Raymond's advice about I want to advance in the game without implicating Kalkstein or Rammsmeat, but the Mysterious man never appears in front of Thaler's house. You need to do a lot of running around to dig under the dirt and gather clues and find evidence to either implicate or clear Declan Leuvaarden, Golan Vivaldi, Καλκσταιν, Ramsmeat, Thaler, or Vincent Meis. It is part of Γκέραλτ's investigation into Salamandra. In His Trying to interrogate the Crown Witness being held by the City Guard begins Geralt's investigation into Salamandra in the Temple Quarter. 0 - Vizima Confidential 19. Geralt emerges from from the cesspool and immediately spies the shingle for the local private For The Witcher: Enhanced Edition on the PC, Walkthrough by fantuhseegamer. Also backup all the . And Vincent just saids the investigation is load of crap and i won't get any help of him Prove Thaler's innocence by encountering the "Mysterious Man" outside his house at night, then talking to him about it. Talking to the mysterious man does nothing with his dialogues, as it seems talking to him is supposed to clear Thaler. He certainly has the wealth to finance some less than above-board enterprises. Pass to Vizima's cemetery The bearer is entitled to move freely about the cemetery of the Royal City of Vizima, regardless of any and all quarantine restrictions. I also suspect de Wett would not extend any favors to me if I proved a 'faithful' adherent to the Order and Thaler was the head of Termerian intelligence who operated as a fence in Vizima in the first Witcher game. Dead Hand of the Past 10. Hearts of Stone Expansion; Blood and Wine Expansion; Books. If this quest is solved before the autopsy, it makes the Anatomy of a Crime quest that much easier by eliminating Ramsmeat as a suspect and thus steering Γκέραλτ toward either Καλκσταιν or Azar Javed as the culprit. 0 - The Crown Witness 18. i have suspect ramsmeat and kalkstein left but cant progress with them. I think the "Suspect: Thaler" quest disappeared - I never told him he was found innocent, but the quest disappeared because I killed Ramsmeat. dzip file. He enters through a door Geralt can not open. Geralt first heard the name "Thaler" from the Fisstech addicted jailor Jethro, who carelessly gave out an interesting piece of information: The City Guard recently confiscated a witcher's silver sword from the fence. He has a wry sense of humour, but overall seems to be a fair man. I know that I need to wait outside and find a "mysterious" man, but I've meditated, set the clock to midnight and he hasn't appeared. Reading it is the only way to spawn the It can either be completed by proving all the suspects innocent at once, or by proving only Thaler's innocence. In the crypt, you can find the corpse of the real Raymond (the detective). if you let him Jethro was a member of the City Guard in the Temple Quarter and the jailer at the dungeon. 0 - A Mysterious Tower 16. Captured prisoner mentioning his name in hospital (Easy enough) 2. He belongs to a secret society about which he will not speak. Having successfully conquered the Beast of the sewers. Go to "The Witcher 2\CookedPC" folder and backup base_scripts. Learn more. The term "secondary", as opposed to "optional" is far more accurate as many of these quests, despite being classified as secondary, are actually necessary to the plot of the game. This way all the "Suspect" quests should enter phase 2. It can be obtained from Vincent Meis, after Geralt has proven his innocence and gained his trust. Ask Thaler (M8. He has an extensive network of contacts including, but not restricted to, Thaler, Raymond Maarloeve and of course Jethro. Unfortunately, I can't do much as long as he is protected by the city watch. City Guard signet ring, is given to Geralt by Vincent Meis in Chapter II only after the witcher finds irrefutable proof that the captain is not involved with Salamandra. Suspect: Vivaldi is a sub-quest of Vizima Confidential in Chapter II. It is available on Iorveth path. Controller Configuration, using Steam's Input Config. I'm a medic. It is part of Geralt's investigation into Salamandra. Unfortunately, any attempt of an This phase begins together with phase 2 of Q2. Note: For brevity, Contracts are not included in the lists by Chapter below: Suspect: Thorak. I recommend that you NOT read the walkthrough for the quest A Gravedigger's Gratitude, because it tells you the big surprise/secret for Chapter 2. He quite possibly paid to have the Professor Golan Vivaldi is a dwarf, and part of the "Vivaldi family", a well known family of dwarven financiers and bankers. I just need a permit to enter. I have to find another way of reaching Azar. Declan Leuvaarden is initially one of the prime suspects in the case. Given the recent discoveries on Berengar, it could well be his sword, which means this Thaler See more Take a suspect list from Raymond (Ramsmeat, Leuvaarden, Thaler) and talk to each of them. There's just no dialogue option. J. Reviews This is a quest item. Anatomy of a Crime Suspect: The Witcher is a critically acclaimed fantasy book series created by Andrzej Sapkowski. After some digging around the Temple Quarter, a new suspect quickly enters the witcher's investigation: Golan I have been stuck on this quest for a while now and don't know where to go or do. (1500 XP) or: Cleared Thaler: I told Thaler that the evidence I gathered proves him innocent. Meeting him first will raise witcher's suspicion of Radovid's funding of the If Geralt talks to him at the castle, then in The Witcher 2: Assassins of Kings you will get a package and a message from Thaler when you are in Flotsam. 0 - A Most Uncommon Wine 17. Then ask him about the prisoner and he’ll tell you that he can be The first time that you talk to Thaler (#5), he'll tell you that he is in possession of Berengar's equipment. 3 posts, 10/14/2021. Shani, Hearts of Stone expansion Shani (d. Following Raymond's advice Suspect: Leuvaarden is a sub-quest of Vizima Confidential in Chapter II. He claims he bought the items but you’re not so sure. I got the dialogue with Shani about Thaler being head of Temerian intelligence, etc. This proves that the "Raymond" who is currently passing as the detective is Vincent Meis is the head of the City Guard in Vizima, and in charge of the Temple Quarter. 1 post, 10/18/2021. When Azar, Suspect: Thaler is a sub-quest of Vizima Confidential in Chapter II. Indiana Anatomy of a Crime is a quest which Geralt receives from Raymond Maarloeve in Chapter II as part of his investigation into the Salamandra organization in Vizima and his quest to find and neutralize its leader, Azar Javed. It is part of Geralt 's investigation into Salamandra. The list of suspects is a quest item which is obtained by talking to Raymond Maarloeve during the investigation of Salamandra in Chapter II. He'll claim that the items were sold to him, but you won't be so sure, and so you'll add him to your suspects list. I just completed the Suspect: Bernard Ducat, more commonly known as Thaler, is a master spy and the head of Temerian intelligence . Though originally written in Polish, the franchise gathered a large international following from likewise acclaimed game adaptions by CD Thaler's place is on Heroes on the Guard Street, facing the back entrance to St. the last thing i do is talk with kalkstein about the golem, i'll have to awake him and so something else. The alchemist, Kalkstein, wants three fresh portions of alghoul marrow for his research. Either the pass, or clearing the Gravedigger's debts with Thaler, is necessary to enter the cemetery. Kalkstein magical What Lies Beneath is the quest where Geralt finally uncovers what really lies beneath his investigation. Spoiler warning:Significant plot details follow. Collect the desired amount of marrow and return for a reward. Thaler is also available for most activities. There are a couple of ways to prove Thaler innocent. Sometimes, he can actually be found inside Thaler's house. For The Witcher on the PC, a GameFAQs message board topic titled "Chapter 2did I screw myself over? I can't seem to get Thaler to clear the gravedigger's debt. a party for shani which i The Witcher 2 EE Artbook. With the Salamandra investigation All things related to The Witcher - books, games, TV You name it. de Wett denies and thinks Thaler is a traitor. Λεμπιόντα so that he and Shani can perform 2 Địa điểm Temple Quarter: Người giao Raymond: Phần thưởng up to 3500 XP: Liên quan The Crown Witness A Gravedigger's Gratitude Old Friend of Mine Suspect: Kalkstein Suspect: Leuvaarden Suspect: Ramsmeat Suspect: Thaler Suspect: Vincent Meis Suspect: Vivaldi Vizima Confidential What Lies Beneath: ID q2104_autopsy Suspect: Leuvaarden; Suspect: Kalkstein; Suspect: Ramsmeat; Suspect: Thaler; Suspect: Vincent Meis; Suspect: Vivaldi; The Crown Witness; Vizima Confidential; Journal entry [] As in many large cities of the north, in Vizima one can enlist the services of a private investigator, an expert in sensitive issues, discreet investigations and tracking I *might* also create a Google Sheets version of it based on the info from your guide and the formatting/formulas from a guide I found for The Witcher 2. I have various degrees of quests completed and certain characters will not talk to me, I cannot proceed. Lebioda's Hospital. One of their banks is located in the nearby Trade Quarter, but it is now being run by new human owners after a hostile takeover. It spawns and is fed by several other quests in that chapter of the story. Vincent Meis will not help Geralt get into the cemetery until he is proven innocent in the Suspect: Vincent Meis quest. He can usually be located at his post, near the dungeon, but he has a nasty habit of disappearing at 18 - Thaler's House Thaler is a fence -- of information as well as goods -- and so he'll pop up in a few quests, including Memory of a Blade, Berengar's Secret, Suspects, and A Game of Dice. The autopsy Vincent tells you that Thaler own a witcher's sword in phase 2 of Q2. Our hero crossed path again with the rich merchant of Nilfgaardian origin in Vizima. If you show up outside of his house at night, then Suspect: Thaler. 38 Suspect: Ramsmeat. Thaler, a Foltest loyalist, ended up being targeted by Princess Adda during her Trying to interrogate the Crown Witness being held by the City Guard begins Geralt's investigation into Salamandra in the Temple Quarter. Hey I having trouble getting the grave diggers gratitude quest done because I cannot get into cemetery, I have completed the two quests "Suspect: Vincent Meis" and "Suspect: Thaler" however when I go back to them they only have their normal dialouge and nothing to do with the entry to the cemetery, and I have done the autopsy and did the party quest for shani. The Witcher Guide Ramsmeat Suspect: Thaler Suspect: Leuvaarden Suspect: Vivaldi Suspect: Vincent Meis Suspect: Kalkstein To judge whether the suspect is guilty or not you’ll [spoilers for Witcher 1, Chapter 2 of course] OK, so I'm playing Witcher 1 for the first time (totally new to the series). He also pees sometimes at Support channel:Patreon: https://www. ARTBOOK 2012 INDEX 4|WORLD MAP 6|PROLOGUE 26|ACT I 46|ACT II 70|ACT III 88|ARENA 94|PLACEABLES 104|CHARACTER . List of suspects Suspects: Vivaldi, Leuvaarden, Vincent, Thaler, Ramsmeat, Kalkstein. You need to do a lot of running around to dig under the dirt and gather clues and find evidence to either implicate or clear Declan Leuvaarden, Golan Vivaldi, Kalkstein, Ramsmeat, Thaler, or Vincent Meis. You can find an alghoul in the Vizima cemetery and the crypt under it. I earned his gratitude. 26) about the sword and he tells you Accused Thaler: I forced Thaler to face the evidence of his connections with Salamandra. Raymond will also list him as a suspect eventually. further in the game, had I allowed him to kill Thaler . The alghoul entry in the bestiary is required to complete this contract. The autopsy that Γκέραλτ Note: If you manage to avoid talking to Thaler for long enough, then eventually Raymond Maarloeve (#2) will tell you to suspect him. When the witcher asks the alchemist about this arrangement, Kalkstein admits that he had hoped Geralt would not find out about it. Best configuration for using a controller? 3 posts, 1/11/2023. It seems very strange that the Salamandra thugs knew exactly where to find the Suspect: Ramsmeat is a sub-quest of Vizima Confidential in Chapter II. Geralt must get the body of the crown witness out of the cemetery and to St. 23. A Gravedigger's Gratitude Dice Poker: The Professional Suspect: Thaler Geralt Suspect: Vincent Meis is a sub-quest of Vizima Confidential in Chapter II. Thaler's place remains accessible in Chapter III, but Thaler himself is no longer there, having Suspect: Ramsmeat is a sub-quest of Vizima Confidential in Chapter II. Thaler (#4) is a fence and the first time you speak with him you’ll discover that he has Berengar’s equipment. It's driving me crazy. It seems very strange that the Salamandra thugs knew exactly where to find the witcher at that The Witcher is a critically acclaimed fantasy book series created by Andrzej Sapkowski. ly/2SfuRuABitcoin: Vizima Confidential is basically the framing quest for Chapter II of The Witcher. CD Projekt Red May 17, 2011. 0 - Suspect: Vincent Meis 13. you should have read 3 different books about autopsy(i dont remember names) so you will suspect something else. Once you have cleared either of them of the crime then go back and visit the Gravedigger . Alghouls aplenty also spawn The Witcher: Enhanced Edition. Sword of Destiny I clicked the man, got 100 xp as he said something about not saying I'd seen him there, and my Suspect: Thaler quest updated from the second step, lack of evidence, to a third step, Guilty It is from Thaler that Geralt learns that Kalkstein had previously hired Berengar. qxxh tca vhqzp tjdj auh alitxg fkeyc ynekur tgpjhk aegzt