Tesla phantom braking

Tesla phantom braking. Dec 13, 2023 · In 2022, the NHTSA also began investigating claims that Teslas using the autopilot feature or cruise control would experience “phantom braking,” or sudden stops while driving, even on highways. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has opened a formal investigation of Tesla over reports of "phantom braking" in 2021-22 Model 3 and Model Y electric vehicles. I had extreme phantom braking on 2 lane roads, usually caused by on coming large trucks. Annapolis Royal, Nova Scotia, Canada. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has opened an investigation into a "phantom braking" problem after receiving hundreds of complaints Feb 17, 2022 · Federal safety regulators have opened an investigation into the 2021 and 2022 Tesla Model 3 sedan and Tesla Model Y SUV because of reports that the vehicles unexpectedly brake while in motion—a Aug 29, 2022 · A California owner of a Tesla Model 3 sued the electric vehicle maker in a proposed class action over cars suddenly stopping for non-existent obstacles, calling it a "frightening and dangerous Feb 17, 2022 · The U. Last year, I visited my brother and his wife on a 4,000 mi tour. google. The phantom braking only got worse with the updates (in addition to new bugs like the window wiper bug). TSLA 3. Dec 5, 2023 · He added that even Tesla employees had spoken to him about vehicles randomly braking in response to non-existent obstacles - known as "phantom braking". Tesla owners are complaining more about "phantom braking Feb 17, 2022 · Per the NHTSA's Office of Defects Investigation (ODI), the agency has received "354 complaints alleging unexpected brake activation in 2021-2022 Tesla Model 3 and Model Y vehicles" over the past I wish there was actual statistics that showed the rate of phantom braking by manufacturer and model. Informatie over ervaringen en theorieën over wat de oorzaak er van is, staat nogal verspreid over verschillende draadjes. #1. 17% over customer complaints that its most popular vehicles brake for unexpected reasons, the latest probe related to the electric Oct 11, 2023 · To better understand this technology and what may be triggering phantom braking, KGW rented a 2022 Tesla Model 3. When FSD or AP cannot figure out the scene up front, it applies the brakes. Sensor Misinterpretation May 31, 2023 · In the last couple of months, all of the hardcore phantom braking I’ve experienced happened when there was an irregularly shaped 18-wheeler far in the distance. x for a bit and had major phantom braking issues when traveling on an interstate under overpasses where the speed limit is 70 MPH. The only way to truly compare is to have the data. By that I mean if you’re in heavy traffic with tailgaters, you might want to keep your right foot hovering over the accelerator in areas where PB has occurred for you. 2,930. Out of the millions of miles that Teslas have driven with automation, there should be multiple reports of accidents if this were truly a problem. and hit last year's "phantom brake" in traffic. The agency is conducting a Feb 17, 2022 · It highlighted a significant increase in Tesla owners reporting dangerous phantom braking events on Autopilot. " Weird. Jan 11, 2023 · A Tesla phantom braking class action lawsuit alleges 2021-2022 Tesla Model 3 and Tesla Model Y vehicles suddenly brake even though there are no objects in the road. #11. Jose Alvarez Toledo said the problems turned his Model 3's "safety feature into a frightening and May 30, 2022 · Which you use depends a bit upon where you are and how likely you perceive phantom braking to occur. com Jun 3, 2022 · The agency began investigating phantom braking in Tesla's Models 3 and Y last February after getting 354 complaints. It received 354 complaints in the past nine months and its Feb 2, 2022 · Owners say their Teslas are suddenly slamming the brakes at high speeds, nearly causing crashes in many cases. Oct 11, 2023 · Phantom braking has been a persistent issue for Tesla vehicles. The probe covers an estimated 416,000 vehicles from the 2021 and Aug 30, 2022 · A Tesla owner from San Francisco filed a proposed class action lawsuit against the electric vehicle company over a phantom braking problem that he claims has turned “a safety feature into a Feb 2, 2022 · The bulk of the complaints recently about Tesla cars have been related to the phantom braking issue — 107, or 57 percent, out of 189 complaints since November about the 2020 through 2022 Tesla Jun 3, 2022 · The US has given Tesla until June 20 to respond to questions about phantom braking incidents — or face up to $115 million in fines. Might even help Tesla avoid a class-action lawsuit for the phantom braking problem if they can’t reduce the phantom braking occurrence rate. It even happened during the reporting of this story. Tesla owners are complaining to the US government about unexpected braking. Wat verschillende Redditor for three years, and remarkably low karma, and their first post to r/TeslaLounge is to draw attention to phantom braking. Keith at Out of Spec Reviews just rode in a driverless Waymo and it had multiple phantom braking events (at least one was a 20 mph drop), deceleration Discussion Blog Hot New Questions Forums Tesla Model S Model 3 Model X Model Y Roadster 2008-2012 Roadster 202X Cybertruck SpaceX The phenomenon, known as "phantom braking," has been documented in videos shared online by Tesla owners. Jan 10, 2023 · Two Tesla owners in North Carolina have filed a class action lawsuit against Tesla claiming their vehicles suffer from a brake defect, otherwise known as ‘phantom braking. 45. Feb 17, 2022 · The government says it has 354 complaints from owners during the past nine months about "phantom braking" in Tesla Models 3 and Y. More than 750 Tesla drivers have complained to the US National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) about unmediated braking manoeuvres of their cars when controlled by the Autopilot system. My personal experience is that I no longer experience the horrible, soul-jarring phantom braking that once occurred. In October 2021, Tesla was forced to “ roll back ” version 10. 294. Naples, FL & Cary, NC. Thanks for the chill mode tip. The probe covers an estimated 416,000 vehicles from the 2021 and 2022 Feb 18, 2022 · The so-called "phantom braking" problem is being looked at by US regulator the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA). It is more than moderately irritating. Phantom Breaking event happened for me 2 yrs back! - a couple times. 7,935. Jan 9, 2022 · Ahh Tesla and radar. But we all understand that basic feature should work within reason. Sep 16, 2020. Hey guys, Just an update to this thread I started over a year ago. One is Fsd will interpret mirages as an oncoming car, and two shadows across my lane from larger vehicles coming also results in significant braking. trisk, TAfirehawk, M3BlueGeorgia and 4 others. 1 with MCU2 FSD and HW3. During the entire trip I got phantom braking, usually every 10-15 minutes, sometimes every couple minutes and sometimes up to 30 minutes Mar 9, 2023 · Los Angeles. Just finished cross country trip in a 2018 Model 3 with 68,000 miles on it. Oct 5, 2019 · Een van de meest vervelende aspecten van cruise control, auto-pilot en FSD zijn de phantom brakes. Phantom braking on Tesla cars has been a concern for some owners. Feb 17, 2022 · Tesla. C. S. #22. According to the Verge, the NHTSA is requesting “all consumer and field reports it has received about false Aug 13, 2019 · Yes, we may discuss it and many can dislike it, but when it is called phantom braking, then it is will be spread as "Tesla has severe phantom braking problem that other cars don't", which is clearly misinformation. x and 2021. I have been in similar circumstances since then and no issues. 23, Tesla updated its Full Self-Driving (FSD) software. I am on 2022. That is a good thing. Feb 19, 2022 · NHTSA is looking into complaints of trouble with the automated emergency braking system in 2021 and 2022 Tesla Model 3 and Model Y electric vehicles. 11, and I'd say the previous release too, we have all sorts of phantom braking again. 11. Feb 2, 2022 · It highlighted a significant increase in Tesla owners reporting dangerous phantom braking events on Autopilot. This was largely due to the radar, and vision, systems having a disagreement on what Feb 2, 2022 · An unidentified 2021 Tesla Model Y driver in Tyler, Texas complained about a near collision with a big-rig truck due to the so-called “phantom braking” of his vehicle. That Nov 15, 2021 · For now, Tesla gets an outsized amount of attention on the phantom braking issue both because of its cavalier attitude towards using public roads as software testing grounds and because it updates Mar 13, 2024 · By comparison, the DOT received more than 700 complaints about so-called "phantom braking," or the propensity for Teslas with autopilot engaged to slam on the brakes for imaginary hazards while in Dec 23, 2022 · Tesla's "phantom braking" problem, already under federal investigation, caused an eight-car pileup in the San Francisco Bay Area last month, according to a report from CNN. Two things have contributed. 44. Associated Press. The real question is why FSD sometimes cannot figure out what's up front, when surely May 26, 2021 · Jan 11, 2023. Tesla must respond to the allegations by 20 June. "My daughter was driving on a freeway at 70MPH and her 2023 Model 3 Jul 18, 2022 · The Verge reports as of early June, 758 Tesla owners reported their phantom braking issues to the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), prompting a letter from the agency asking the company for more information. The lawsuit alleges the automaker has been aware of the defect for years but continues to sell their cars to buyers. This is for Vision only - so you should either have no-radar Tesla or you are on FSD Beta. Hopefully it makes sense. Without the traffic you can be a bit more relaxed. Again, in the past year the phantom braking problem has largely been eliminated on both of my Tesla cars. Apr 6, 2023 · Colorado. At night though, it's every 30 seconds. May 27, 2023 · A Tesla owner filed a lawsuit against the electric vehicle maker last August over phantom braking. This trip was all 4 lane interstate, so I haven't yet tested it on 2 lane highways. NHTSA opened up an investigation into potential "phantom braking" problems with Tesla Model 3 and Model Y EVs in February because it has heard complaints from 350 drivers about the issue Feb 17, 2022 · Tesla owners’ complaints of phantom braking to NHTSA spiked to 107 in the three-month period before Feb. Phantom braking is unsettling and seems like it could cause a rear ending incident but I've yet to hear of a single case where this has happened. Aug 25, 2006 · The phantom braking is not eliminated by using radar. Apr 12, 2023. Phantom braking was minimal with the software just before going to camera only rather than radar + camera. I had also head on collision warnings as well on two lane roads where the speed limit was 45 MPH. Aug 4, 2023 · Transport Canada has confirmed it’s investigating “phantom braking” in Tesla vehicles, as newly obtained information shows the agency has received hundreds of complaints about that and other Jul 15, 2022 · Settings that may mitigate "Phantom Braking"Here's a few of the settings in your Tesla Model 3 that may help lessen the incidents of "phantom braking" or "fa Feb 2, 2022 · Tim Levin. Apr 23, 2022. Feb 17, 2022 · Some 350 complaints by Tesla owners saying their cars can stop on roads for no apparent reason and they feared rear-end crashes on freeways. I would bet 15- 20 incidents in a one hour drive in light traffic. I’m loathe to blame it on just ditching radar. But I was on a trip and left without giving a demo in my Model 3. I never had huge issues with phantom braking on the old car, but jeez, this new Y is terrible! Maybe it's the loss of USS, or radar (but I thought this was all disabled anyhow back when all-vision Jan 6, 2020 · While we’re on the topic of recalls, there is a large article in today’s Washington Post about phantom braking problems with Tesla vehicles and the current NHSTA investigations into the issue. Feb 17, 2022 · Tesla owners sometimes refer to the unexpected brake activation as “phantom braking. 3. Earlier this year, the federal agency launched a formal investigation into Nov 2, 2021 · On Oct. Oct 30, 2020 · Results from my range tests, banana box tests and other goodies here:https://drive. So George and his wife took a Model Y for a test drive . Then some owners say that their non-Tesla’s have frequent/occasional/never phantom braking. Their vehicles suddenly slam the brakes, often on open roadways, quickly slowing in response to imagined hazards. "Phantom braking" is the act of slowing down for shadows, overpasses, overhanging trees, passing a truck/lorry, etc. Jan 27, 2024. After receiving 354 complaints, NHTSA opens preliminary evaluation into reported instances of "phantom braking" by Tesla vehicles with Autopilot advanced driver-assist system engaged. Coming from 3 yr old model 3 owner — I had to post today given the news out — Tesla’s radar-less cars investigated by NHTSA after complaints spike It was so bad an experience that I had to post it here to vent out. Tesla already gets singled out for phantom braking. After 10 months of ownership I traded in the tesla for a non-ev at a ~$30k loss (the tesla was $70k when I got it in Dec 2022 and I got $40k trade in for it, it had 4400 miles on i Dec 8, 2022 · My worst phantom braking frequency happens on desert type highways in the day time. 3 of its Full Self-Driving beta software because of the issue. See full list on makeuseof. FSD is an evolving collection of features Jun 3, 2022 · Tesla Inc. Jul 17, 2019 · Yeah, yeah - another thread on this I recently replaced my 2019 Model 3 with a new Model Y. I used cruise control for probably 90% of the trip, but never used autopilot. auto-safety regulator is investigating Tesla Inc. Now I can't use CC or FSD at night at all because the car freaks out every time a car's headlights appear on the road. The last leg of my journey on exclusively two lane roads provided t Apr 25, 2019 · The phantom braking is what I get when Im driving on a interstate on a sunny day, no cars in front or behind or beside me, and I approach an area where trees are casting random shadows onto the roadway and the speed goes from 65mph in the car, down to 50mph rather quickly because FSD (still) is thinking the shadows are actual objects on the road. 25. 12. If there is no vehicle detected / no change in the within scope surrounding environment, it might mean there is a glitch and the vision processing has been jammed for unknown reasons. The Tesla vehicles are equipped Oct 8, 2020 · That is adjusting to bad speed limits. NHTSA estimates that the investigation covers Apr 23, 2022 · 336. 30. Phantom braking started long before vision only systems. She has FSD, although I rarely use it. Dumb cruise control means no phantom braking means less chance Tesla keeps getting singled out for phantom braking. is facing stepped-up scrutiny from US regulators who have received 758 complaints of cars made by the company that suddenly brake at high speeds, more than double the number of reported Jun 3, 2022 · Federal regulators are asking Tesla for more information on certain 2021-2022 Model 3 and Y vehicles. Sep 15, 2020 · Sep 29, 2015. Aug 25, 2006 · Have some of the recent FSD builds resolved the phantom braking issues? I did a monthly subscription in the past but opted out due to multiple incidents. Phantom braking is a term used to describe when an advanced driver assistance system Feb 18, 2022 · After picking up my Model Y in Atlanta, I began my journey back home to Colorado Springs. ’. At least 750 Tesla owners have reported their cars randomly braking without reason while they Jun 9, 2022 · The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration is moving along in an investigation to look into consumer reports of phantom braking in 2021-2022 Tesla Model 3s and Model Ys. Yes, phantom braking can be a thing with any Tesla model with adaptive cruise control that is a part of basic autopilot, enhanced AP and FSD. During the day time the phantom braking is only an occasional annoyance, perhaps only happening every 1/2 hr or so on road trips. But ever since 12. In February 2022, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration launched an investigation into “Unexpected Brake Activation Aug 6, 2022 · Tesla to answer for phantom braking issues. #2. Auto Pilot and TACC is technically Beta. Their vehicles suddenly slam the brakes, often on open roadways, dropping in speed in Aug 30, 2022 · Tesla sued over ‘phantom braking’ Tesla is on the other side of the docket in the state of California where a Model 3 owner is suing the company over a “phantom braking” defect. Additionally, the merging has reverted to the horrible previous pattern of waiting until upcoming traffic is right off the left rear quarter to start signalling, and no matter that there are three cars stacked up Feb 2, 2022 · Phantom braking was a rare event before going to FSD Beta. People keep blaming vision as the exclusive reason for phantom braking. 10 and phantom braking is all over the place, especially in some areas; yesterday had to disengage 3 times. Seems unclear if this problem is related to sensitivity of the new Tesla Vision system vs the older radar sensors. phantom breaking coupled with unexpected moves into non-proper lanes (I was on AP yesterday, exiting off I75 and instead of staying in the two exit lanes it decided to veer into the exit safety area) make this Tesla's worst update in quite some time. pongajim said: I'm on 22. “When driving on a two Jun 3, 2022 · The agency said its investigation into phantom braking in Tesla's Model 3 and Y started last February after getting 354 complaints. We drove from Portland to the Idaho border — roughly 750 miles round-trip. Mar 9, 2023. Model S electric vehicle for sale outside a dealership at the Easton Town Center Mall in Jun 9, 2022 · Tesla. Acknowledging these probable causes can aid in resolving and preventing the problem. Jan 12, 2023 · The California Highway Patrol has released a series of surveillance videos showing the moment a Tesla Model S changed lanes and braked on the Bay Bridge on Thanksgiving, causing an eight-car pileup. I've had my Model 3 since Sept 2018 and I think Tesla is in a string of really sucky code. Jun 5, 2022 · The inexplicable and potentially dangerous phantom braking problem on Tesla's electric cars is back in the limelight, and this time, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has revealed that the number of complaints has more than doubled in only four months. A few months ago, I could barely use cruise control because it was braking so often (hard brakes, like 20mph drops). 4. Tesla phantom braking is an unexpected occurrence that can occur for many different reasons. NHTSA is investigating complaints about Autopilot’s automated emergency braking system (AEB) involving more than 400,000 vehicles after drivers reported so-called phantom braking May 10, 2020 · The shadow of the truck in the right lane was cast into the center lane and had hard phantom braking - immediately took over and accelerated out of it. Dec 12, 2022 · 1. . Feb 18, 2022 · The US government is investigating reports of Tesla cars braking unexpectedly on motorways. I bragged on how AutoPilot relieved a lot of driving stress. That is what I understood is supposed to be fixed in the latest version. Feb 19, 2024 · Phantom braking cost a sale. Some 354 Dec 5, 2023 · In August 2023 one San Diego father submitted the following complaint after she experienced phantom braking in her new Tesla. That is a disorienting situation and triggers a safety alert as I understand they are under investigation, but haven't heard anything from Tesla themselves. #6. Menu icon A vertical stack of three evenly spaced horizontal Feb 17, 2022 · Tesla. This was largely due to the radar, and vision, systems having a disagreement on what Feb 2, 2024 · Let me help you. 2, the Washington Post reported, compared with just 34 complaints in the previous nearly Feb 17, 2022 · The agency said Thursday it’s launching a preliminary evaluation of unexpected braking by Tesla Model 3 sedans and Model Y sport utility vehicles. This goes against the gospel of Elon. Passing trucks to their right is certainly a problem and on occasion with cars too. deets: Texas, 2022 M3LR, 11. Oct 4, 2021 · Aug 30, 2022. ” A Tesla Inc. com/open?id=1HOwktdiZmm40atGPwymzrxErMi1ZrKPPGet 30 day free trial Mar 6, 2019 · So if one were to be driving along in a regular car, and somebody suddenly blindfold your eyes, your first reaction would be to apply the brakes. Good thing too. 6. My guess is that FSD thought the 18-wheeler was much closer since it doesn’t have a good grasp on the shape. While there is still some room for Tesla to Jun 10, 2021 · I had 2021. TACC and Collision avoidance has always used cameras. Tesla Phantom Braking Fix: Possible Causes and Fixes. Phantom Braking is a moniker given to when the Teslas still had a radar in them and would brake for literally no reason at all. The Feb 17, 2022 · NHTSA said phantom braking occurs when owners use cruise control or Autopilot, Tesla's driver-assistance system that brakes, accelerates, and steers on the highway. I don't think they know what causes it completely yet. Not since - for whatever reason. May 8, 2020 · Phantom braking was minimal. Just as a point of reference, I am currently on 20. 5 M3 LR Dual Motor. Feb 18, 2022 · Tesla is facing a new headache this week. As of last month Dec 20, 2021 · Tesla has started to release a new Full Self-Driving Beta software update (10. Dec 8, 2022 · Here is a poll to crowdsource Highway Phantom Braking experience stats. Jul 18, 2022 · Arbe Robotics. Feb 2, 2022, 9:26 AM PST. #3. Tesla drivers report a surge in ‘phantom braking’. 3. Het leek me goed hier een apart topic over te starten. 7) that improves the situation with “phantom braking” and even helps the FSD beta be more energy efficient. I just did a 750 mile road trip and had 0 phantom braking events. The next morning, the automaker began receiving phantom braking complaints from owners. The probe covers the 2021 and 2022 model years. Phantom braking is a term used to describe when an advanced driver assistance system Nov 14, 2023 · Phantom braking has been documented in videos shared by Tesla owners. Feb 17, 2022 · Phantom braking has been an ongoing issue for the automaker. Some owners say that their Teslas have frequent phantom braking, some say occasional, some say never. Dec 12, 2022 · Here is a poll to crowdsource Highway Phantom Braking experience stats. I have a 2017 Model X and 2018 Model 3, and they behave mostly the same. TresLA said: They’re confusing the phantom braking issue (although much less of an issue than before) with the intentional safety feature of slowing down when driving much faster than traffic in adjacent lanes as indicated by the chevrons on the display. Some of the typical reasons and the fixes for Tesla phantom braking include the following: 1. The lawsuit was filed by Michael Costello, a Tesla Oct 10, 2023 · A KGW investigation documented hundreds of complaints about Tesla cars slamming the brakes for imagined hazards. Feb 17, 2022 · NHTSA is investigating reports of phantom braking in the Tesla Model Y and Model 3 while Autopilot is active, Consumer Reports says. "In addition to the safety recall in late October, the timing of the complaints coincides with a period in which Tesla has stopped using radar sensors in its vehicles to supplement the suite of cameras that perceive their surroundings. In the past few weeks, I've driven the same roads 6 times and had absolutely no phantom braking. Nine people were Redditor for three years, and remarkably low karma, and their first post to r/TeslaLounge is to draw attention to phantom braking. ii kl tq xk of kv mv im fu tq